TIGblogs TIG | TIGblogs GROUP TIGBLOGS LOGIN SIGNUP
Toronto PHP Developer
Toronto PHP Developer
Dire Messages About Global Warming Can Backfire, New Study Shows

Dire or emotionally charged warnings about the consequences of global warming can backfire if presented too negatively, making people less amenable to reducing their carbon footprint, according to new research from the University of California, Berkeley.

“Our study indicates that the potentially devastating consequences of global warming threaten people’s fundamental tendency to see the world as safe, stable and fair. As a result, people may respond by discounting evidence for global warming,” said Robb Willer, UC Berkeley social psychologist and coauthor of a study to be published in the January issue of the journal Psychological Science.

“The scarier the message, the more people who are committed to viewing the world as fundamentally stable and fair are motivated to deny it,” agreed Matthew Feinberg, a doctoral student in psychology and coauthor of the study.

But if scientists and advocates can communicate their findings in less apocalyptic ways, and present solutions to global warming, Willer said, most people can get past their skepticism.

Recent decades have seen a growing scientific consensus on the existence of a warming of global land and ocean temperatures. A significant part of the warming trend has been attributed to human activities that produce greenhouse gas emissions.

Despite the mounting evidence, a Gallup poll conducted earlier this year found that 48 percent of Americans believe that global warming concerns are exaggerated, and 19 percent think global warming will never happen. In 1997, 31 percent of those who were asked the same question in a Gallup poll felt the claims were overstated.

In light of this contradictory trend, Feinberg and Willer sought to investigate the psychology behind attitudes about climate change.

In the first of two experiments, 97 UC Berkeley undergraduates were gauged for their political attitudes, skepticism about global warming and level of belief in whether the world is just or unjust. Rated on a “just world scale,” which measures people’s belief in a just world for themselves and others, participants were asked how much they agree with such statements as “I believe that, by and large, people get what they deserve,” and “I am confident that justice always prevails over injustice.”

Next, participants read a news article about global warming. The article started out with factual data provided by the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change. But while half the participants received articles that ended with warnings about the apocalyptic consequences of global warming, the other half read ones that concluded with positive messages focused on potential solutions to global warming, such as technological innovations that could reduce carbon emissions.

Results showed that those who read the positive messages were more open to believing in the existence of global warming and had more faith in science’s ability to solve the problem. Moreover, those who scored high on the just world scale were less skeptical about global warming when exposed to the positive message. By contrast, those exposed to doomsday messages became more skeptical about global warming, particularly those who scored high on the just world scale.

In the second experiment, involving 45 volunteers recruited from 30 U.S. cities via Craigslist, researchers looked specifically at whether increasing one’s belief in a just world would increase his or her skepticism about global warming.

They had half the volunteers unscramble sentences such as “prevails justice always” so they would be more likely to take a just world view when doing the research exercises. They then showed them a video featuring innocent children being put in harm’s way to illustrate the threat of global warming to future generations.

Those who had been primed for a just world view responded to the video with heightened skepticism towards global warming and less willingness to change their lifestyles to reduce their carbon footprint, according to the results.

Overall, the study concludes, “Fear-based appeals, especially when not coupled with a clear solution, can backfire and undermine the intended effects of messages.”

Source: Yasmin Anwar, UC Berkeley Media Relations
###

For more information about this study, please contact: Matthew Feinberg at matthewfeinberg@berkeley.edu.

The APS journal Psychological Science is the highest ranked empirical journal in psychology. For a copy of the article "Apocalypse Soon? Dire Messages Reduce Belief in Global Warming by Contradicting Just World Beliefs" and access to other Psychological Science research findings, please contact Keri Chiodo at 202-293-9300

November 19, 2010 | 10:34 AM Comments  0 comments

Tags:
You must be logged in to add tags.


Rob's Profile


Latest Posts
With NDP surging,...
Dire Messages About...
Actors tell CRTC to...
Peel Public Health...
Illinois governor...

Monthly Archive
May 2003
June 2003
August 2003
September 2003
October 2003
November 2003
December 2003
January 2004
February 2004
May 2004
July 2004
August 2004
September 2004
November 2004
December 2004
March 2005
May 2005
October 2005
February 2006
March 2006
June 2006
July 2006
November 2006
December 2006
January 2007
February 2008
August 2008
December 2008
October 2009
November 2009
November 2010
April 2011

Change Language


Tags Archive
barack clinton differin dufferin government laws mccain obama ontario peel privacy propaneexplosion rodblagojevich smoking toronto unjust wilson

Links
Ajax Developer
Ancient History
Arbor Day
Artificial Flower
Arts Craft
Auras
Auto Game
Auto Suggestion
Babies Names
Bahaullah
Baseball Game
Basketball Game
Biographical
Biorythm
Breeds
Bugs Insects
Business Letter
Canadian Short Stories
Card Trick
Catholic Prayer
Children Stories
Christmas Story
Clovers
Cricket Game
Difficult
Dyeing
EBooks for Free
Election Game
Emigrants
Fiction Stories
Fogs
Football Game
Forensic Medicine
Forgeries
Free Jokes
Games Kids Play
Genghis Khan
Give Up
Handwriting Analysis
Heavy Metal Music
Herb Gardens
Histories
Home Dentistry
Home Gardening
Home Made Cookies Recipes
Home Medicine
Home Plumbing
How to Draw
Href
Inconsiderate
Informational Site Network
Insane Asylum
Intelligence Test
Learn Camping
Left Hand
Listens
Martin Luther King
Martyrs
Math Puzzle
Mediumship
Mediumship
Military Training
Mind Reading
Mix Martial Arts
Money Investing
Monophysitism
Mormonism
My Dreams
Mystery Stories
News Stories
Occultism
Operatic
Overcoming Fear
Palm Readings
Pet Stories
Pigment
Playing Card Games
Postal Stamps
Prays
Prophecies
Protectionism
Psychic Research
Reincarnated
Romance Stories
Rosicrucian
Scary Stories
Sea Stories
Sings
Siouan
Smoke Free Places
Soccer Game
Software Developer
Speaking Writing
Stargaze
Steel Making
Stories Poetry
Superstitions
Sustainable Farming
Tax Sale Property
Tea Leaf
Telepathic
Tennis Games
The IChing
Tudors
Urban Myths
Wall Decor
Wedding Stories
White Magic Spells
Wine Cultivation
Woodworkings
Work Rights
World Maps
World Wars
Xlf
Yrd


76267 views
Important Disclaimer